Compare Florida Marine Insurance Providers
Side-by-side comparison of America's top marine insurers — find the right coverage for your Florida vessel
Get a Quote NowTop Florida Marine Insurance Providers
In-depth profiles to help you find your best match
🌊 FloridaCover
We match every Florida boater to their best-fit insurer
- ✓Access to multiple A-rated Florida marine insurers
- ✓Florida-specialist marine insurance advisors
- ✓Vessels from jet skis to superyachts. All types covered.
- ✓Agreed value and actual cash value options across carriers
- ✓Hurricane and storm coverage expertise
- ✓Caribbean and Bahamas navigation extensions
- ✓Fast response. Quote within 24 hours.
- +One form, multiple provider quotes compared for you
- +Florida-specific expertise across all waterways
- +Covers all vessel types from PWC to luxury yacht
- +Advisors know local risks: hurricanes, offshore, Keys
- +No cost to compare. Pay only when you choose cover
Progressive
America's #1 boat insurer by policy count
- ✓Agreed value and actual cash value options
- ✓Total loss replacement for newer boats
- ✓Uninsured/underinsured boater coverage
- ✓Disappearing deductible program
- ✓On-water towing and assistance
- +Highly competitive premiums for recreational boats
- +Strong digital tools and easy online quoting
- +Wide range of discounts available
- –Less tailored for high-value superyachts
- –Some coverage limits lower than specialist insurers
- –Customer service can vary by region
Online or phone claims available 24/7. Marine claims specialists handle vessel damage assessments. Average claim resolution 7–14 days for straightforward claims.
BoatUS / GEICO Marine
America's boating association, trusted by millions
- ✓Includes BoatUS membership benefits
- ✓Nationwide towing network on land and water
- ✓Agreed value policies for most vessels
- ✓Total loss coverage with new boat replacement
- ✓Wreck removal coverage included
- +Industry-leading towing network (800+ locations)
- +Deep marine expertise. Boat-only insurer.
- +Strong agreed value policies
- –Requires BoatUS membership for best rates
- –May not be the cheapest for simple small boats
- –Limited commercial fishing coverage
Dedicated marine claims team available by phone. BoatUS field surveyors can assess damage on-site. Known for fair and fast settlement of hurricane claims.
Markel
Specialist marine underwriter for serious boaters
- ✓Agreed value policies. No depreciation on total loss
- ✓Extended navigation areas including Caribbean
- ✓Liveaboard coverage available
- ✓Commercial endorsements for charters
- ✓Professional crew liability
- +Specialist marine underwriting expertise
- +Excellent for offshore and bluewater vessels
- +Comprehensive agreed value policies
- –Premiums can be higher than mass-market insurers
- –May require survey for older or high-value vessels
- –Less focused on small recreational boats
Dedicated marine claims adjusters with specialist knowledge. Survey-based claim assessments for significant damage. Strong track record for offshore and bluewater claims.
Chubb
Prestige marine insurance for high-net-worth owners
- ✓No-depreciation agreed value on hull and equipment
- ✓Worldwide navigation with Caribbean/Bahamas included
- ✓Professional crew P&I included in package
- ✓Loss of use and charter income protection
- ✓Fine art and valuables coverage aboard
- +Unmatched coverage for high-value yachts
- +Concierge-level claims service
- +Worldwide navigation coverage included
- –Significant minimum premiums. Not suitable for small boats
- –Requires professional survey for most vessels
- –Higher premiums than standard market
White-glove concierge claims process. Dedicated senior adjusters for high-value claims. Access to preferred marine repair yards. Known for fast and fair resolution.
Foremost
Reliable protection for everyday Florida boaters
- ✓Broad recreational boat and PWC coverage
- ✓Bundling discounts with home and auto
- ✓Watercraft liability coverage
- ✓Comprehensive and collision options
- ✓Medical payments coverage
- +Good bundling discounts through Farmers network
- +Accessible premiums for entry-level boats
- +Broad PWC and recreational coverage
- –Less marine-specialist than dedicated boat insurers
- –Limited offshore and extended navigation options
- –Claims may be handled by generalist adjusters
Claims handled through Farmers Insurance network. Phone and online reporting available. Local agent support for smaller claims. Average resolution 10–21 days.
Quick Comparison
| Provider | Rating | From | Financial Strength | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🌊 FloridaCoverRecommended | ★★★★★ | Quotes from multiple carriers | Multiple A and A+ rated carriers | All Floridians: from weekend fishing and party boats to charter captains, commercial operators and liveaboards |
| Progressive | ★★★★★ | From $150/yr | A+ (AM Best) | Recreational boaters and value-conscious owners |
| BoatUS / GEICO Marine | ★★★★★ | From $175/yr | A++ (AM Best) via GEICO | BoatUS members and frequent cruisers needing towing |
| Markel | ★★★★★ | From $250/yr | A (AM Best) | High-value vessels, offshore cruisers, and liveaboards |
| Chubb | ★★★★★ | From $1,500/yr | A++ (AM Best) | Luxury yachts, superyachts, and high-value vessels |
| Foremost | ★★★★★ | From $120/yr | A (AM Best) | Small to mid-size recreational boats and personal watercraft |
Premium estimates are indicative only. Actual premiums depend on vessel type, value, usage, and individual underwriting criteria.
Match Me to the Right Insurer
Tell us about your vessel and we'll match you to the best-fit Florida marine insurer within 24 hours.
Get a Quote →